Red One delivers a festive, action-packed romp that breathes new life into the holiday movie genre. While not without its flaws, the film offers enough heart, humor, and inventive storytelling to make it an enjoyable addition to the large stable of Christmas films. Despite mixed reviews and a disappointing box office projection, Red One deserves a second look for those searching for a holiday film that mixes traditional elements with an unconventional twist.

The Red One narrative centers on a unique take on the Christmas mythos, blending action, adventure, and fantasy with a touch of darkness. Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson stars as Callum Drift, one of Santa's E.L.F.s who is tasked with rescuing the famous man with the bag in order to save Christmas from a magical threat. The plot finds its antagonist in the villainous Gryla, a Christmas witch portrayed with icy brilliance by Kiernan Shipka. Her plan is deceptively simple and cleverly understated, presenting a unique twist that doesn’t rely on over-the-top stakes, yet personally affects most people worldwide.

The story surprises with moments that are darker than expected for a holiday movie, lending it an edge that older audiences can appreciate while still maintaining the whimsy that kids love. The blend of classic Christmas motifs with new mythological elements enriches the film’s universe and sets the stage for potential expansions into other holiday tales—a tantalizing possibility that may go unexplored due to poor box office results.

Dwayne Johnson, as expected, plays to his strengths as Callum Drift, bringing his trademark charm and physicality. While Johnson’s persona is beginning to feel a bit familiar, it fits the character well enough to keep audiences entertained. However, it’s Chris Evans and J.K. Simmons who truly shine in their respective roles. Evans brings a surprising depth and comedic touch to his character, making him more than just a sidekick to Johnson’s lead. And while the trailers might have hinted at a modern, gruff reimagining of Santa Claus, Simmons offers a surprisingly traditional, heartfelt take that grounds the story in classic holiday sentiment.

Kiernan Shipka’s Gryla is a standout as well. She portrays her with a compelling mix of menace and allure, making her both a formidable foe and an intriguing character. Her nuanced performance, alongside her character’s deceptively clever plan, brings a refreshing villain to the holiday movie landscape. It's Kristofer Hivju, however, who nearly steals the show as Krampus, playing the part with a mischievous and wild energy that injects humor and unpredictability into the film. His performance adds a delightful layer, making Krampus a memorable supporting character that enhances the movie’s mythology.

The film’s cinematography strikes a balance between the fantastical and the festive. Wide shots of snow-laden landscapes and cozy, twinkling towns blend with dramatic close-ups during tense confrontations. The visual palette is rich with reds, whites, and deep greens, encapsulating the holiday spirit while integrating darker blacks, blues, and purples into the shadowy scenes that signal Gryla’s presence. And though the special effects don’t always hit the mark— some CGI moments are downright bad —they don’t detract from the overall enjoyment. This is, after all, a holiday film, where a little suspension of disbelief goes a long way. The whimsical tone helps the audience overlook these inconsistencies.

The soundtrack features a mix of classic Christmas songs and original score, both of which add warmth and urgency to the film. The music swells appropriately during action sequences and mellows during tender, nostalgic moments, aiding the emotional tone without being overpowering. The makeup team, meanwhile, excels in their portrayal of mythological characters. JK Simmons’ Santa is a blend of traditional looks with a rugged twist, complete with silver-streaked hair and a leather outfit that still feels familiar. The standout, however, is the detailed work on Krampus, making Kristofer Hivju’s character visually captivating. The practical effects on the more fantastical characters shine, contrasting with some of the CGI’s weaker moments.

Red One might not be perfect, but it’s absolutely worth the watch. It’s a film that embraces the magic, warmth, and occasional darkness of the holiday season. Ignore the critics, gather the family, and enjoy this fun, unconventional take on Christmas lore. It might just find its place in your annual holiday movie rotation as I can guarantee you it has mine.