By Brandon T. McClure (@btmcclure @fakenerdpodcast)
The MCU, specifically the Infinity Saga (2008-2019) has meant a great deal to me, as I am sure it has for many people. What first started as a book pitch is now a series of essays of mine that will be (hopefully) published every week. The goal is to pick a specific moment within The Infinity Saga and share with you why I believe it’s a defining moment. To revisit previous posts, visit our site HERE.
Enjoy the ride as we count down from 50 of the most defining moments and share your thoughts in the comments.
• A FIRST DANCE •
MOMENT# 48
MOVIE: Avengers: Endgame
DIRECTORS: Joe and Anthony Russo
WRITERS: Christopher Marcus & Stephen McFeeley
Steve Rogers (played by Chris Evans) and Peggy Carter (played by Hayley Atwell) dance in Avengers: Endgame
Steve Rogers has had a rough journey through the course of the MCU. Frozen in time, betrayed by the government he swore to protect, forced to fight his friend to save his other friend, and then half the population of the universe is snapped away. While Steve didn’t constantly struggle with living in the modern world, it was never easy for him. When he had a second chance, knowing the world would be safe, he took it.
One of the major through-lines of Captain America: The First Avenger is that Steve has never danced with a woman. After all, he figured he’d wait for “the right partner”. When he meets Agent Peggy Carter, he realizes that she was that partner he was looking for. The events of Captain America’s origin film also play out as a love story between Peggy and Steve. There’s clearly an unspoken love between them, but they just can’t find the right time. During the climactic moments of the film, they make a date for that first dance. Sadly, Steve never makes it to his 8:00pm date at the Stork Club. When he finally does reunite with Peggy, she’s grown old and is suffering from dementia, but he couldn’t leave his best gal. The doomed romance of Peggy Carter and Steve Rogers is one for the ages.
The time-traveling events of Avengers: Endgame see the Avengers take the Infinity Stones from different points in history so they can bring back the 50% of the universe that Thanos snapped away. Steve and Tony have to retrieve the Tesseract (the Space Stone) from the 1970s, and there, in an old S.H.I.E.L.D. bunker, Steve sees Peggy for the first time since attending her funeral in Captain America: Civil War. When Thanos is defeated and Steve is sure the world will be safe without him, he gives his best friend, Bucky, one final hug and leaves the timeline to return the stones and find that life he’s been missing.
The film ends with their first dance.
Whenever there’s talk about endings within the MCU, most always point to Iron Man. Since Tony was the MCU’s first hero, his ending was a major point of interest for many. Unlike comic books, the characters in the MCU will age and eventually have to be written out. Early on, there was a lot of talk of recasting, much in the same way as Mark Ruffalo replaced Edward Norton. As the franchise went on, recasting became a harder task. Marvel Studios couldn’t just recast Robert Downey Jr. or Chris Evans. Audiences had developed an emotional attachment to these characters, and the actors who played them over the years. Having anyone else in the role would be a hard sell.
Avengers: Infinity War, already prepared audiences for what Avengers: Endgame was going to bring, but a happy ending seemed like a pipe dream. Giving Steve Rogers a happy ending shows that not every character has to go out in a blaze of glory. Sometimes, they can get everything they want. Steve Rogers was able to have the life he longed for, the life he didn’t feel he could have because of his responsibility to the world. A happy ending was given to a character that was beloved. Steve Rogers was allowed to ride off into the sunset, live the life he was robbed of with the woman he always loved. For Steve, there was no more “what could have been”. Now Captain America didn’t have to disappear, a new timeline could be formed where Steve lived a happy life with Peggy. One can’t help but wonder what that other timeline was like…