By Anthony Caruso
Wicked: Part One is everything I hoped it would be and more. As someone who has seen the Broadway show five times, I hold Wicked close to my heart—it’s my favorite musical of all time. My expectations for this movie were sky-high after waiting two decades for it, and not only did it meet those expectations, it exceeded them in every way. This adaptation is a breathtaking masterpiece that had me in tears, feeling full-body chills, and brimming with joy. It’s a magnificent tribute to Act One of the stage show and an extraordinary feel-good crowd-pleaser evocative of old Hollywood, making it my personal pick for movie of the year.
Cynthia Erivo and Ariana Grande are nothing short of perfect as Elphaba and Glinda. Their portrayals are nuanced and magnetic, bringing warmth, humor, relatability, and heartbreak to their characters. Erivo’s Elphaba is as powerful and empathetic as you’d expect, but Grande as Glinda is a revelation. She delivers an effortlessly charismatic performance that steals the show, blending humor, vulnerability, and dazzling vocal prowess. Her rendition of “Popular” alone had me grinning from ear to ear. Both actresses are sure to earn Oscar nominations, and while Erivo’s powerhouse performance deserves recognition, I wouldn’t be surprised if Grande walks away with Best Supporting Actress. She was born for this role - and I say that as somebody who was initially extremely wary of her casting upon its announcement!
The supporting cast is equally brilliant. Michelle Yeoh’s presence as Madame Morrible and Jeff Goldblum’s whimsical yet menacing Wizard are tantalizing previews of what’s to come in "Part Two". Jonathan Bailey’s portrayal of Fiyero deserves special praise, however. He elevates a character I’ve always liked well enough into someone I adore. Bailey brings a depth, charm, and charisma to Fiyero making his journey deeply compelling.
Oz itself, meanwhile, has never felt so real. The production design, costumes, and practical effects are phenomenal, creating a vibrant, immersive world full of detail and wonder. From the emerald glow of the city to the verdant forests and bustling streets, every frame is brimming with life and authenticity. And the restrained use of CGI is both unexpected and a triumph. Apart from the magical "Animals" and a few scenes toward the end of the movie, most of the sets and props feel tactile, transporting you straight into this magical world. It’s a refreshing throwback to a time when blockbusters relied heavily on practical artistry, further reinforcing the movie’s timeless, Old Hollywood feel.
The musical numbers are the film’s heartbeat, and every single one is pitch-perfect. The choreography is not just fun, but dazzling, while the rearrangements of Stephen Schwartz’s iconic score are fantastic, adapting beautifully to the screen without losing any of their theatrical power. “Defying Gravity” is, of course, the emotional high point, and it had the entire theater in stunned silence before erupting into applause. But the standout numbers don’t stop there! “No One Mourns the Wicked” sets the film’s tone masterfully. “What Is This Feeling?” is delightfully playful. “Dancing Through Life” showcases both stunning choreography and Jonathan Bailey’s charm. “One Short Day” is a visual and auditory feast, brimming with wonderful surprises. Every song feels lovingly translated, retaining its emotional weight and theatricality while embracing the cinematic medium.
Director Jon Chu, alongside writers Winnie Holzman and Dana Fox, has created a film that is both faithful to the Broadway production and innovative in its execution. Chu’s passion for the source material shines through in every frame. He seamlessly blends elements of the stage musical with additional backstory from Gregory Maguire’s novel and entirely new material that enriches the narrative. The film also pays loving homage to the 1939 classic, The Wizard of Oz, from visual motifs to subtle musical cues woven into the score by Stephen Schwartz and John Powell. These references don’t feel forced, but instead enhance the story, bridging the gap between the beloved original film and this contemporary masterpiece, and I'm curious to see how "Part Two" continues to do that, making the stories gel more seamlessly together than even the Broadway show managed to do.
Wicked: Part One captures the magic of classic musicals like The Wizard of Oz while feeling modern and fresh. It’s a rarity in today’s blockbuster landscape: a movie that is colorful, emotionally resonant, extraordinarily timely, and brimming with hope. The production values, storytelling, and performances come together to create something truly special. When the explosive finale culminated in the words “To Be Continued,” the audience in my theater erupted into cheers and applause. There were even spontaneous ovations after several musical numbers throughout - a testament to how much this film resonated with the crowd.
In the end, I feel confident in saying this is not just the best musical adaptation I’ve seen in years, but may very well be the best since The Wizard of Oz. Wicked: Part One is destined to become a classic. It’s sure to be an awards contender, a box-office juggernaut, and an unforgettable experience for fans and newcomers alike. I can’t wait to watch it again multiple times in theaters and revisit it often when it hits home media, and I will eagerly be counting down the long days until the release of "Part Two". Until then, I’ll be reliving this extraordinary experience in my mind and listening to the film's soundtrack on repeat. Whether you’re a fan of the musical or have never seen it before, I urge you to see Wicked: Part One on the biggest screen possible. It’s am absolute triumph in every sense of the word.